Is It Better to Repair or Replace My Damaged Roof?

by Jul 5, 2023

If your roof is showing signs of aging, such as missing shingles, broken shingles, or dents in your metal roofing, you may be wondering whether it’s better to repair the damaged areas or opt for a complete roof replacement. Making the right decision depends on several factors. Here are some helpful tips and guidelines to assist you in determining the best course of action for your specific situation.

The barrier of a roof on a home is important in keeping the rain, snow, sun, and extreme temperatures where they belong. Likewise, the protection a good quality roof provides your family and possessions must be kept working in tip-top shape. If either of these fails, the comfort of your family is sacrificed. A regular inspection of your roofing system will help maintain peace of mind by keeping the weather out, and your family safe and comfortable inside. 

If a roof is not in good condition, unfortunate things can happen. Pests, leaks, mold, mildew, or debris from the latest storm are all examples of what can happen to a roof in Wichita. When these events do happen, Is it better to replace or repair a roof? That depends on a variety of factors. (Learn more about how long the life span of roofs)

Roof Repair

Consider the Age of Your Roof

Different roofing materials have varying life expectancies. For instance, asphalt roofs can last anywhere from 15 to 30 years, but this can be significantly reduced if regular inspections and maintenance are neglected. On the other hand, metal roofs typically have a longer lifespan of 35 to 50 years, again contingent on regular inspections.

Implementing a regular maintenance program involves visually inspecting your roof and identifying areas of vulnerability. Once you’ve detected these areas, it’s advisable to consult with a professional roofing contractor in Wichita to determine whether the damage can be easily repaired or if it necessitates more extensive measures. In Wichita, consider reaching out to Rhoden Roofing. We can assess your roof’s condition and provide recommendations tailored to your specific needs.

Address Leaks Promptly

If your roof has developed areas where water seeps through, it’s crucial to take swift action. Whether you should have roof repair or replace the affected portion depends on the extent of the damage. Minor areas can often be fixed by replacing a few shingles. However, if there’s a significant hole that has compromised the underlayment and insulation, a roof replacement may be necessary.

Evaluate Weathered and Worn Areas

Are there sections of your roof with curling or broken shingles, as well as missing granules? If these issues are widespread across the roof, it may be more practical to opt for a complete replacement rather than attempting to patch up individual areas. Mixing new shingles with worn ones can result in an unappealing aesthetic. To make an informed decision in such circumstances, it’s advisable to consult with Rhoden Roofing for professional advice on the best course of action.

Consider the Following Guidelines when determining whether to repair or replace: 

  • Old, worn, and weathered roofing material
  • Moss, mildew, or algae have taken over
  • Asphalt or wood shingles exhibit curling, cupping, or bent edges
  • Areas with missing granules or bald spots are present
  • Metal panels show signs of rust

roof damage, roof repair, roof replacement, Wichita

Compare Repair Costs with Replacement Costs

Once you’ve identified the areas of damage, it’s essential to consider the cost implications of repair versus replacement. If the repairs are minor and your roof still has a significant lifespan, repairing the damaged sections may be the most cost-effective choice. However, if the damage is extensive and the costs are comparable, replacing the entire roof can provide the peace of mind that comes with a new roof. To make a price comparison and finalize your decision, it’s best to consult with a trusted professional.

We have published a whole Cost Series that goes into many more details on specifics of various repairs and replacement options to help give our community a sense for what to expect for costs and to be able to make an informed decision about what’s best for their particular situation.

What Happens in a Roof Repair? 

This is something to consider when the cost involved, and the amount of damage done are factored in. When done properly, the life of your current roof can be extended and, in some ways, could be quite beneficial. The repair work might involve replacing shingles or sheeting in a particular area and then replaced. It is best to discuss the job with a trusted roofing professional, to get their best advice. 

What are the Steps Involved in a Typical Roof Repair? 

  • A thorough inspection of the area – This should be done by a local roofing contractor. They can give you proper advice on the work to be completed.
  • Obtaining proper permits. Again, something your local roofing contractor knows how to accomplish. Many towns have rules and regulations which must be followed carefully to eliminate future fines and unforeseen costs
  • Home preparation –  Tarps and protective material should be placed over your landscaping and property for easy and safe cleanup
  • Roof Repair – The damaged part of your roof can now be fixed.
  • Clean-up – Removal of old roofing materials and debris
  • Final Inspection – This should be done to make sure everything was completed properly and will hold the integrity of the rest of your roofing.

What Happens in a Roof Replacement?

If the damage to your home is too much for a few repairs, a full roof replacement must be considered. This process is complex and involves much more detailed steps to complete. Perhaps this would allow the homeowner to upgrade to a different roofing system if the budget will allow it. Consulting with a local roofing company knowledgeable in the various roofing systems can offer you the pros and cons of each system. 

Rhoden Roofing is Wichita’s most trusted roofing company! We offer a lifetime material warranty and a 100% guaranteed lifetime workmanship warranty. We are Wichita’s Eagle Readers Choice Award Winner for 9 consecutive years. We stand behind our work, no matter what the job requires. We offer a customer-first philosophy. Our reputation of honest, polite, and professional work speaks for itself. 

Roof Replacement

What are the Steps Involved in a Typical Roof Replacement? 

  • A thorough inspection of the area – Just like a roof repair, it is wise to begin the process knowing just what the roof is like. Are there spots of damage to be cautious around? A skilled team of professionals will know what to look for and keep everyone safe. 
  • Obtaining proper permits – Again, a local roofing company will know just which rules and regulations apply to properly complete the job.
  • Preparing the site – Considering a huge mess will be made by removing an old roof, a considerate company will place dumpsters and tarps in proper areas to keep your property protected. 
  • Removal of old roofing – Remove the old roofing and assess the decking to determine its stability, specifically looking for areas of mold, mildew, and or rot that need replacing. 
  • Preparing the deck – Install the proper decking to support the new roofing system. 
  • Install a new roof – Lay the new roofing material down 
  • Clean up – Once the new roof is installed, clean up must be completed and all items properly disposed of. 
  • Inspection – Final assessment to make sure the roof is installed properly, and the homeowner is pleased. 

There is much to consider when choosing between a roof replacement or a roof repair. Speaking with a professional roofing contractor can help answer any questions you may have. At Rhoden Roofing, our performance and your satisfaction is everything to us. We use the best products and materials available, and we will complete the project to your 100% satisfaction. No excuses. We also offer free inspections and recommendations to your specific property. 

Call us today to discuss how we can help you and your roofing needs. 


This article is part of our Storm Response Series. Learn more about:

Latest Posts